Talks to Watch

No Béarla Series 1, Episode 1.

256K views · Nov 13, 2011 · 25:30 · 1 HN recommender · 3 mentions · discussed 2020–2025

The first episode of the Irish TV series No Bearla, in which native Irish speaker Manchan Magan travels around Ireland trying to get by using only Irish. It documents the highs and lows of the attempt.

Why Hacker News points people here: Cited in threads on minority languages as a funny but sad look at how hard it is to live in Irish.

“No Béarla[1] is one of the saddest documentaries I've ever seen.”HN comment, 2025

What Hacker News said 3

RecommendsDiogenesKynikosApr 2020

“There's a funny TV series that explores how useful the Iris”

Funny series on how useful Irish is.

Full comment

Hebrew is the only successfully revived language that I know of, and it was revived under circumstances that are really pretty unique. Irish has had "national language" status for 100 years, during which time it has continued to decline. Strong government support for the language - making it a requirement for government jobs, teaching it to schoolchildren, defining regions of the country where Irish should be the primary everyday language - weren't enough to prevent the continued decline of the language. I think the problem with the sort of language policy that Ireland pursued is that language is a practical tool for most people. A lot of people liked the idea of Irish coming back (especially back when speaking Irish was a political statement against English colonialism), but in everyday life in Ireland, English is vastly more useful. The last monolingual Irish speaker died in 1998.[1] You will never encounter anyone who only knows how to speak Irish. Back when there were monolingual Irish speakers, they lived in some of the poorest areas of Ireland and hoped that their children would learn English, so that they would have better opportunities. In some ways, the language policy backfired. Some people actually viewed it as oppressive, because they didn't see the point of learning a language that was of no practical use to them in everyday life, and they weren't able to get certain jobs unless they spoke that language. There's a funny TV series that explores how useful the Iris

in “The many languages missing from the internet” · view on HN
Cites itfrabbitJul 2020

“The scenes in which he attempts to get state-run tourist services to communicate with him in one of the official lanaguages of Ireland are painful.”

Protagonist tries to get services in Irish.

Full comment

By coincidence I was just watching an 8 year old Teilifís na Gaeilge (TG4) program in which the protagonist attempts to travel the length and breadth of Ireland speaking only 'as Gaeilge'. The scenes in which he attempts to get state-run tourist services to communicate with him in one of the official lanaguages of Ireland are painful. In particular his visit to the prison cell in which his grandmother (one of the 1916 revolutionaries) was incarcerated starts off badly: this video

in “Survival of Scottish Gaelic in doubt” · view on HN
Cites itxdennisJul 2025

“No Béarla[1] is one of the saddest documentaries I've ever seen.”

Native speaker struggles to do mundane tasks in Irish.

Full comment

> whose first language is Gaelic Is that really true though? I think it's a bit optimistic to say "first language". I know that many people do speak Irish, but the number of people who can speak Irish better than English is abysmal. No Béarla[1] is one of the saddest documentaries I've ever seen. It follows a native speaker who tries to do mundane tasks in Ireland using only Irish, but can barely get anything done. [1]: this video