2.8M views · Jul 24, 2019 · 38:55 · 3 HN recommenders · 5 mentions · discussed 2020–2024
Irving Finkel of the British Museum lectures at the Royal Institution on the invention and decipherment of cuneiform writing in Mesopotamia, and why it is so hard to translate.
Why Hacker News points people here: HN users recommend it as a delightful, well-told account of how cuneiform developed and was decoded.
“Highly recommend Prof Irving Fink's talk to Royal Institution on the 3,000 year development of cuneiform”HN comment, 2023
“Irving Finkel's lectures are marvelous.”
Delightful, polished lecture on the decipherment of cuneiform.
Irving Finkel's lectures are marvelous. Watching his lecture on the decipherment of cuneiform is a delight, both in subject matter and in the delivery of a well worn and thoroughly polished presentation. (If only all professors were so articulate and passionate.) this video
“Highly recommend Prof Irving Fink's talk to Royal Institution on the 3,000 year development of cuneiform”
Covers cuneiform's 3,000 year development, reading and decipherment.
Cuneiform clay tablets have a survival advantage over other materials, so it's anyone's guess when the first well-defined symbolic representation of spoken language system was invented, it may have been lost to history entirely. Highly recommend Prof Irving Fink's talk to Royal Institution on the 3,000 year development of cuneiform, how it is read, and the story of its decipherment: this video
“Here[1] is a video covering how cuneiform (the writing system) was deciphered”
Covers how cuneiform was deciphered.
Here[1] is a video covering how cuneiform (the writing system) was deciphered, most of it was solved after they found an inscription in three different languages. [1] this video
“There's a really good Royal Institution talk on cuneiform and how difficult it is to translate”
Talk on cuneiform and how difficult it is to translate.
They found cuneiform tablets, that's pretty fascinating. There's a really good Royal Institution talk on cuneiform and how difficult it is to translate: Cracking Ancient Codes: Cuneiform Writing - with Irving Finkel this video
“It's a fascinating story, well told by Irving Finkel”
Fascinating story of cuneiform decipherment, well told.
The earliest surviving written records - the clay tablets of ancient Mesopotamia - are mostly collections of data, taxation records and so on. It was something of a disappointment to scholars when cuneiform was deciphered that their materials didn't record many epic poems, but rather a whole lot of internal revenue information. It's a fascinating story, well told by Irving Finkel: this video The vast majority of data being collection today is similarly uninteresting - maybe the surveillance state likes it as a means to control politicians by threatening to expose their porn watching habits or similar, and certainly targeted advertising has made some people wealthy, but it's not even well-curated, and it's certainly not the kind of valuable data that comes out of well-designed and controlled experiments, and thus 'big data science' is one of the most over-hyped fields in existence today.
