Tom Murphy (suckerpinch) shows 'reverse emulation', using a Raspberry Pi in an NES cartridge to give an unmodified NES new abilities such as playing SNES games. The video starts in a strange way and gets stranger.
Why Hacker News points people here: Praised as a brilliant, deadpan and inventive hardware hack, and a good starting point for Tom7's videos.
Reverse emulation uses a Raspberry Pi as an NES coprocessor
Full comment
Along these lines, Tom7 invented* 'reverse emulation' which effectively uses a Raspberry Pi as a co-processor, allowing him to run [spoilers ahoy!]an SNES emulator on an NES.[/spoilers] The talk is brilliant: this video * - as far as I know...
Strongly recommendssgroveDec 2020
“As usual for his videos, it's absolutely wonderful.”
Hacks a real NES cartridge with a Raspberry Pi emulator
Full comment
In that case, you might like one of tom7's many wonnderful videos [0], "Reverse emulating the NES to give it SUPER POWERS!" where he hacks a real NES cartridge with a raspberry pi with an emulator, then figures out how to map all of the data into NES sprites, etc. As usual for his videos, it's absolutely wonderful. [0] this video
Strongly recommendsGuestHNUserApr 2022
“His dead pan delivery coupled with the ridiculous amount of effort he puts into things that don't _really_ matter is honestly inspiring.”
Deadpan, ridiculously elaborate projects that inspire
Full comment
Tom7 is brilliant for anyone that hasn't seen him before. His Reverse Emulation video ( this video ) and Weird Chess Algorithms ( link ) are a must watch. His dead pan delivery coupled with the ridiculous amount of effort he puts into things that don't _really_ matter is honestly inspiring.
Strongly recommendsanyfooJun 2022
“though really, they are all fantastic”
Good starting point among fantastic videos by Tom7
Full comment
You will love Tom7/suckerpinch's stuff then, if you don't know him already. Here's a good one for the start, though really, they are all fantastic: this video
Strongly recommendspinkmuffinereOct 2025
“Tom7 is one of my favorite people, he is hilarious, has an amazing technical depth, and so much whimsy to go along with it.”
Favorite Tom7 video, hilarious with technical depth and whimsy
Full comment
Tom7 is one of my favorite people, he is hilarious, has an amazing technical depth, and so much whimsy to go along with it. I'll proselytize for him all day! relevant video: link less relevant, but I think my favorite: this video
RecommendsrrherrDec 2018
Listed among best talks of 2018, Deconstruct conference
Full comment
From Deconstruct: Nabil Hassein: Computing, Climate Change, and All Our Relationships link Tom 7: Reverse emulating the NES to give it SUPER POWERS! this video
RecommendsprogvalApr 2020
“you can skip to 3:35 if you're not interested in the jokes”
Reverse-emulated NES with a Raspberry Pi, jokes can be skipped
Full comment
This reminds me of this video of a "reverse-emulated" NES using a raspberry-pi: this video (you can skip to 3:35 if you're not interested in the jokes). The author further explains how he did it in this "making of" video: link
RecommendsjerfJul 2021
“still worth it.”
Best watched without spoilers, worth it
Full comment
Well, then do I have the video for you: this video Bit of a spoiler to post it in this context, but still worth it.
Recommendsbla3Mar 2022
“If you liked this, you'll likely also enjoy”
Fun to watch without knowing the punchline in advance
Full comment
What a great article. If you liked this, you'll likely also enjoy this video I'm not giving a summary since that video is most fun to watch if you don't know the punchline in advance. (No relationship to the video other than that I liked it.)
RecommendsjabbanySep 2022
“it reminds me of this gem”
Uses a modern device to give old hardware extra capabilities
Full comment
Heh, it reminds me of this gem: this video which does something similar... using a modern device to give old devices essentially capabilities beyond what they should be able to do.
RecommendsNotYourLawyerDec 2022
“Great YouTube channel.”
Raspberry Pi in an NES cartridge doing crazy things
Full comment
Great YouTube channel. Here’s a fun video where he integrates a raspberry pi into a NES cartridge to do all kinds of crazy things using the NES’s native hardware. Spoiler alert: full-motion video of the rickroll video is not the craziest thing he manages to pull off. this video
RecommendsiamevnJul 2023
“Anything that catches your eye is good but my favorites are”
Among the commenter's favorite videos by the channel
Full comment
Anything that catches your eye is good but my favorites are: 30 Weird Chess Algorithms: ELO World link Reverse Emulating the NES to give it SUPER POWERS! this video
Cites itdjsumdogMay 2019
“even a guy who use a Raspberry Pi to emulate an NES cartridge and get his unmodified NES to play SNES games”
Example of Raspberry Pi making an NES play SNES games
Full comment
People still run Commodore 64s. There are demo scenes, old hardware enthusiasts that squeeze crazy performance out of old hardware, even a guy who use a Raspberry Pi to emulate an NES cartridge and get his unmodified NES to play SNES games: this video Old hardware can often be repaired. If you told a C64 user back in the day his machine would break in two years, he or she wouldn't shell out the $$ on it, but today people buy $400~$800 cellphones that turn into garbage.
Cites itmrobSep 2019
“Tom Murphy implemented this with a Raspberry Pi”
Example of Raspberry Pi cartridge feeding data to the NES PPU
Full comment
Note that some of these features require special hardware support in the cartridge. The NES cartridge connector exposes CPU and PPU (picture processing unit) pins, and the simplest games ("NROM") connect ROM chips directly to them. More advanced designs add an additional memory management controller (commonly called a "mapper"): link The animated backgrounds are accomplished by the mapper bank switching the character (tile) memory. The parallax scrolling is accomplished by the mapper counting scanlines and generating an interrupt when the correct scanline is reached, so the CPU can change the PPU scroll registers mid-frame with the correct timing. Later mappers like the the MMC5 could precisely time mid-frame bank changes to support more than 256 tiles on screen at once, and to support 8x8 attribute blocks instead of 16x16. The ultimate mapper feeds arbitrary data to the PPU to simulate having a bitmapped display with 8x1 attribute blocks (the PPU only reads attribute memory once every 8 pixels, so that's a hard limit). Tom Murphy implemented this with a Raspberry Pi (which isn't ideally suited to the task, so there are timing imperfections causing graphical glitches, but theoretically it could be done without them): this video
Cites itpdkl95Nov 2019
“a very creative hack”
Quotes the cartridge-as-dual-of-the-console line, calls it creative
Full comment
LOL... from "Reverse emulating the NES to give it SUPER POWERS!"[1] (which is insa^Wbizza^Wa very creative hack): "The cartridge is the dual of the Nintendo." [1] this video edit: for a very impressive variation on the SMW "joke" in [1], I recommend this[2] video of TASbot streaming Skype realtime to [2xNES, SNES+SuperGameBoy] through the controller ports . [2] link
Cites itroywigginsDec 2021
Prior example of adding a modern coprocessor to old console hardware
Full comment
Well, that's been done also: this video Also, commercial 3D SNES games sometimes had to bring their own coprocessors, so it's fully in line with tradition: link
Cites itsilverlyraNov 2023
Footnote link, loosely tied to the hierarchy of foundational tools
Full comment
When seeing Prettier as a software tool, to consider Prettier more “foundational” than (e.g.) TypeScript or V8 does seem like an inversion of hierarchy [1] – but viewed as history, as a practice, Prettier’s accomplishment of making automatic code formatting (à la `go fmt` or Python `black`) widespread in JavaScript, the lingua franca of programming, is foundational. All that time spent staring at code that could have been more readable, or writing style guides and reformatting code, is now spent doing what we were trying to do in the first place. And now, speeding up the time we wait to apply formatting or check it in CI by rewriting it in Rust™ gives us a bit more of that time back. :) [1]: this video
Cites itmrguyoramaJan 2024
Compared to reverse emulation of the NES
Full comment
>It uses a 16mips pic (64hz 4-cycle) driving 1K of an 8k dual port ram. This is much closer to the "Reverse Emulation" of the NES that this video did than playing a movie on the actual device. Using the original hardware as nothing more than an RF output interface is clearly not the same work, though just like in the reverse emulation of the NES, it is still a neat thing. The reason video on original IBM 5150s is so neat to most people is that it could have reasonably been done in it's heyday if we could take knowledge and algorithms back in time, which the reverse emulation versions could not.
Cites itderefrJan 2024
Link appears incidental to the legacy x86 discussion
Full comment
That you can plug legacy x86 extension hardware into the board, and have it find a bug-for-bug-compatible x86 system to talk to on the other end. A major use-case being embedded systems — e.g. industrial control systems. These systems use a combination of 1. custom hardware — usually in the form of peripheral cards — built to speak old legacy x86-only bus protocols like ISA; and 2. old custom software, designed to run on an x86 CPU (usually in DOS), and to speak directly to that hardware over that bus. You can't just find some USB adapter for the old hardware's bus, because the software won't take it. And you can't just replace the old software, because the new software (whether a newer version of the old software, or software from another vendor) won't control the old card; and the card speaks an even lower -level (probably analogue!) protocol specific to the industrial system. Often, on these old systems, the custom peripheral card is still working due to it being solid-state (and thank god for that; the card's vendor is probably long-gone!) but the old x86 box the card lived in for the last 40 years is dying of various old-computer maladies — or just can't be made to fit into a new form-factor forced by a newer generation of the industrial system being controlled. In such a case, you ideally want to find a new embedded host system, made of new parts that will last you the next 40 years, but which can nevertheless still talk in very specific, custom, low-level ways to your
Cites itDweditFeb 2025
Example of cartridges containing full computers feeding the PPU
Full comment
"Cartridge that works on a stock NES" is muddied waters now, since a cartridge can contain a full computer that feeds data directly to the PPU bus, while the main NES CPU mostly runs idle. See "DOOM on NES": link or Reverse emulating the NES to give it SUPER POWERS this video