1.6M views · Jun 16, 2020 · 12:20 · 2 HN recommenders · 4 mentions · discussed 2020–2021
Yuta, a Japanese YouTuber, tests how much simplified Chinese a Japanese person can read, working with a Mandarin speaker. The video shows where shared kanji help and where meanings differ.
Why Hacker News points people here: HN uses it to answer whether Japanese speakers can read Chinese: they can guess a lot, but not reliably.
“That Japanese Man Yuta has a great video demonstrating just how much Chinese script do ordinary Japanese folk understand”HN comment, 2020
“That Japanese Man Yuta has a great video demonstrating just how much Chinese script do ordinary Japanese folk understand”
Shows how much Chinese script ordinary Japanese understand
That Japanese Man Yuta has a great video demonstrating just how much Chinese script do ordinary Japanese folk understand: this video
“I found these videos quite entertaining”
Entertaining videos on familiar characters with different meanings
>there's a bunch of stuff that kind of looks like it would make sense when reading a Chinese word in Japanese, but turns out there's a lot of meanings are very different As someone who knows nothing of the Japanese language beyond the very basics, I found these videos quite entertaining: link this video It looks like many characters are familiar to his respondents, but their combinations make absolutely no sense.
“the short answer is "you can guess, but don't expect it to be exactly correct".”
Answers whether Japanese speakers can read Chinese
You are not the first one who has asked that question. In case you can't watch videos right now, the short answer is "you can guess, but don't expect it to be exactly correct". link this video
“Japanese people can vaguely infer the meaning of mandarin, given the simplified characters”
Japanese can vaguely infer simplified Mandarin
Mostly yes. Japanese people can vaguely infer the meaning of mandarin, given the simplified characters, without prior exposure to the language before: this video
