Talks to Watch

India Driving

10.3M views · Mar 22, 2006 · 2:14 · 0 HN recommenders · 3 mentions · discussed 2010–2018

A short 2006 clip of chaotic traffic in India, with cars, bikes and pedestrians weaving around each other and one car going against the flow.

Why Hacker News points people here: HN uses it as the classic example of chaotic Indian traffic, especially in threads about self-driving cars and spontaneous order on roads.

“You might have seen this internet classic”HN comment, 2018

What Hacker News said 3

Cites itjustboxingJul 2017

“Related video => [2006] India Driving”

Related video of chaotic Indian traffic.

Full comment

Forget the part about protecting jobs, how confident will the driverless cars companies be even otherwise, sending their cars out into the chaotic traffic in India, where you routinely share the road with bicycles, motorcycles, scooters, rickshaws, handcarts, buses, lorries (trucks), cows and the occasional sheep and donkeys? Related video => [2006] India Driving this video

in “India will ban driverless cars in order to protect jobs” · view on HN
Cites itYeGoblynQueenneSep 2018

“You might have seen this internet classic”

Classic video showing chaotic Indian driving.

Full comment

>> On the other hand, I'm sure people in India or China will be happy to build and deploy them with much higher failure rates. You might have seen this internet classic: this video [India Driving] Driving in India is notoriously chaotic and if self-driving cars are ever deployed there in our lifetime, they will come with a safety guarantee about equal to a car driven by a blind dog with a missing paw. It would be impossible to safely navigate the streets there with anything less situationaly aware than a fully developed adult human brain. The article above makes it sound like weather is the big problem for self-driving cars and once that's solved- wooohoo, we're on our way! It's far from that. Self-driving car AI is still incapable of reasoning about its environment, neither does it have any "undersanding" of it in any way, shape or form. Consequently it only works in very limited environments, in very limited conditions - of traffic, visibility, road quality etc.

in “Self-Driving Cars Can Handle Neither Rain nor Sleet nor Snow” · view on HN
JokemuhfuhkuhAug 2010

“I'm not sure about this, Batman.”

Full comment

So, the future of less traffic congestion is to be like the developing countries: India: this video Vietnam: link Hmmm... I'm not sure about this, Batman.

in “Spontaneous order on the road (what happened when traffic lights were off)” · view on HN