Talks to Watch

(1/4) Intro/History: Introducing a 100-year-old mechanical computer

476K views · Nov 11, 2014 · 3:39 · 6 HN recommenders · 8 mentions · discussed 2015–2023

The first of four short videos from Bill Hammack (engineerguy) introducing and giving the history of a 100-year-old mechanical computer, Michelson's harmonic analyzer. The series goes on to explain Fourier synthesis, analysis and operation of the machine.

Why Hacker News points people here: Commenters recommend the series whenever Fourier analysis or analog computing comes up, praising Hammack's clear explanations and the short episodes.

“There is a series of four fantastic videos”HN comment, 2021

What Hacker News said 8

Strongly recommendsJshWrightFeb 2018

“If you haven't watched all of Bill's videos, you should put them on your list right right now.”

Series on a century-old device that mechanically performs Fourier transforms.

Full comment

If you haven't watched all of Bill's videos, you should put them on your list right right now. His early stuff was a great mixture of goofy humor and fascinating explanations of the engineering behind various everyday objects. His more recent stuff has (unfortunately, in my opinion) dropped most of the comedy, but really stepped up the overall quality. Some highlights: His series on Faraday's Chemical History of a Candle lectures: link His series on Albert Michelson’s Harmonic Analyzer (a century old device that can mechanically perform Fourier transforms) this video I'd also really recommend his book on R101, the last great British airship. link

in “The Engineering of the Drinking Bird Toy [video]” · view on HN
Strongly recommendsamaticDec 2021

“There is a series of four fantastic videos”

Series about Michelson's Harmonic Analyzer.

Full comment

There is a series of four fantastic videos about a successor to Thompson's tidal analyzer - the Michaelson's Harmonic Analyzer; here is the first video: this video

in “Analog computers were the most powerful computers for thousands of years [video]” · view on HN
RecommendsQuequauAug 2018

“I bet you would enjoy Bill Hammack's series explaining how a 100 year old mechanical harmonic analyzer works.”

Explains how a 100-year-old mechanical harmonic analyzer works.

Full comment

It's not in use today but if you haven't already seen it, I bet you would enjoy Bill Hammack's series explaining how a 100 year old mechanical harmonic analyzer works. this video

in “Tide-Predicting Machine No. 2” · view on HN
Recommends_edoSep 2019

“if you're into this sort of thing here's the first in a seven video series”

Series on Michelson's mechanical Fourier-analysis harmonic analyzer.

Full comment

Very cool. Also, if you're into this sort of thing here's the first in a seven video series on a very different mechanical computer - Albert Michelson's Harmonic Analyzer which does Fourier Analysis: this video

in “UCLA’s 1948 Mechanical Computer [video]” · view on HN
Recommendstasty_freezeSep 2021

“Although it is multiple parts, each one is very short.”

Short episodes on a mechanical Fourier synthesizer and analyzer.

Full comment

If you like this, you might also like Bill Hammack's series on a mechanical version of a fourier synthesizer (OK) and analyzer (wow!). Although it is multiple parts, each one is very short. this video As a side note, the guy who designed it was Michelson, famous for the Michaelson/Morley experiment that disproved the existence of the luminiferous ether.

in “Fourier Series Visualisation with D3” · view on HN
RecommendsdghughesJan 2023

“If not here it is it's a great watch.”

Series showing a Fourier analysis machine.

Full comment

Many here probably have seen The Engineer Guy's series of videos showing a Fourier Analysis machine. If not here it is it's a great watch. this video

in “The Fourier Transform, explained in one sentence” · view on HN
Cites itfnordfnordfnordJun 2015

“A series of four videos detailing the operation of a mechanical computer for plotting Fourier series.”

Four videos on a mechanical computer plotting Fourier series.

Full comment

Another, prior art, so to speak. this video A series of four videos detailing the operation of a mechanical computer for plotting Fourier series.

Cites it082349872349872Dec 2023

“we've come a long way from”

Mechanical analyzer, contrasted with modern computation.

Full comment

we've come a long way from: this video (incidentally research into automated tidal calculation was sponsored by the Royal Navy, because they didn't want their ships to get stuck off somebody's coast, in plain sight for hours after having rendezvoused, just because they missed a suitable tide for landing marines...)