Veritasium traces analog computers from the Antikythera mechanism and Kelvin's tide-predicting machines to fire control and modern analog approaches. It explains how these machines computed continuously rather than digitally.
Why Hacker News points people here: Recommended in threads on analog computing, photonic chips, AI hardware and tide prediction as an engaging history of Kelvin's machines.
“His video before this one[1] goes into detail on that, and it was incredible.”HN comment, 2022
“His video before this one[1] goes into detail on that, and it was incredible.”
Details Kelvin's tide-predicting analog computers; incredible history.
Full comment
In the intro to this video he mentions analogue computers predicting tides. His video before this one[1] goes into detail on that, and it was incredible. In the 1800s, Lord Kelvin spent years working on tidal rise and fall patterns, applying Fourier Transforms to break them down into ten individual sine waves, then combining those sine waves back together to predict future tides. And built analog computers to do all the involved integration, multiplying and summing. It's a part of the history of computing I'd never heard of, despite hearing quite a lot about the dawn of electro-mechanical computers in the early 1900s. [1] this video
RecommendsWJWJan 2022
“It's quite fascinating how they even managed to do basic Fourier transforms without electricity”
Tide-computing analog machines doing Fourier transforms without electricity.
Full comment
You might be interested in the analog computers that were used to compute tide tables back in the day. It's quite fascinating how they even managed to do basic Fourier transforms without electricity: this video
RecommendscultofmetatronMar 2022
“here's two youtube videos that explain is much better than I could.”
Explains analog computing hardware better than commenter could.
Full comment
basicly, we can do things like matrix operations and differntial equations using specialized hardware that performs computation over analog signals rather than buidlign discrete systems. the end result is that we dont' need anywhere near the level of compute to do the job as its done using an analog of the physical process. here's two youtube videos that explain is much better than I could. this videolink suffice to say, your average house fly exhibits behavior that absolutely dominates our best drones and with a fraction of the circuitry.
Recommendswoojoo666Jun 2022
“Veritasium has two great videos on it”
Two great videos on analog computing in AI.
Full comment
It's a big area of research in AI. Veritasium has two great videos on it: linkthis video I found a hackernews discussion for the second one: link
RecommendsnicoJun 2024
“There is a very good Veritasium video that talks about analog computers”
Covers analog computers and Kelvin's tide prediction machine.
Full comment
There is a very good Veritasium video that talks about analog computers and Lord Kelvin’s tide prediction machine: this video
Recommendso4cDec 2025
“Veritasium made a great video on Kelvin's Tide-predicting machine in 2021.”
Kelvin's tide-predicting machine.
Full comment
Veritasium made a great video on Kelvin's Tide-predicting machine in 2021. Title: The Most Powerful Computers You've Never Heard Of URL: this video
Cites itfaeyanpiraatDec 2021
“There is an upcoming Veritasium video about the "comeback of analogue computers".”
Teaser of upcoming analog computing video.
Full comment
There is an upcoming Veritasium video about the "comeback of analogue computers". Part one (teaser): this video
Cites itabalajiFeb 2022
“The author mentions they were inspired by the Veritasium video on the same topic”
Inspiration for the Lego tide predictor.
Full comment
The author mentions they were inspired by the Veritasium video on the same topic (without the Lego). [1] I thought I'd link the previous HN discussion. [2] [1] this video [2] link
Cites itktpsnsMar 2022
“The first one was”
First of two Veritasium videos on analog computers.
Full comment
The product presented: link made by link The company presented: link This is the second video (of a series of two) by Veritasium about analog computers. The first one was this video and discussed on Hacker News at link
Cites itmcdonjeJun 2023
“Veritasium did a couple of videos on analog computing a year ago.”
Veritasium's analog computing videos from a year earlier.
Full comment
That's really neat. Veritasium did a couple of videos on analog computing a year ago. I'm glad there are people lowering the barrier to entry. this videolink
Cites itmbivertOct 2023
Cited for engineer's dream about anti-aircraft gun accuracy.
Full comment
Adding to this list of unorthodox approaches, by modern standards: I've heard in some French conferences of Etienne Klein (I'm not sure how romanticized this is though) that Einstein had some breakthrough while being in a half-asleep state. Here's another similar instance[0][1], better documented, of an engineer working on an automatic level recorder, and "realizing" in a dream that it could be used to improve the accuracy of anti-aircraft guns (WWII). [0]: link [1]: this video
Cites itjodrellblankDec 2023
“until last year's Veritasium video on YouTube[2] about analog computers”
Learned Kelvin invented tide-predicting analog computers.
Full comment
I used to know nothing about Lord Kelvin except he said things like " It seems, therefore, on the whole most probable that the sun has not illuminated the earth for 100,000,000 years, and almost certain that he has not done so for 500,000,000 years "[1] and allegedly "everything which can be discovered, has been discovered"; until last year's Veritasium video on YouTube[2] about analog computers, and learned he invented tide-predicting analog computers to "substitute brass for brains" and add sinusoidal curves, and a mechanical integrator to separate out individual sinusoidal frequencies from the sum. [1] link [2] this video from about 3 minutes.
Cites itshagieAug 2024
“the tide calculator plays a prominent part of the video.”
Tide calculator plays a prominent part of the video.
Full comment
The Thomson (also known as Lord Kelvin of degrees K fame) tide predicting machine takes us back to the late 1800s. link One implementation of it was a notable part of WWII: > They came to be regarded as of military strategic importance during World War I, and again during the Second World War, when the US No.2 Tide Predicting Machine, described below, was classified, along with the data that it produced, and used to predict tides for the D-Day Normandy landings and all the island landings in the Pacific War. link From Veritasium : The Most Powerful Computers You've Never Heard Of - the tide calculator plays a prominent part of the video. this video (the next video is also in the same topic - Future Computers Will Be Radically Different link and that gets into more modern implementations and uses - link is the device shown in the video).
Cites itnosianuDec 2025
Example that math is more than symbol manipulation.
Full comment
So... I remember math including doing quite a bit of geometry by hand and with real tools, at least initially. "Math" is not just the symbol stuff written with a pencil, or with a keyboard. The mechanical analog computers of old (e.g. this video , or link ) are examples too that math is more than symbol manipulation.
