6.8M views · Oct 6, 2014 · 2:58 · 2 HN recommenders · 8 mentions · discussed 2015–2025
Tom Scott explains why Britain historically has separate hot and cold taps rather than mixer taps, tracing it to how water was stored in tanks. He notes why the hot tap is not safe to drink from.
Why Hacker News points people here: HN commenters treat it as the standard short answer whenever UK taps come up.
“Short video by Tom Scott on the subject for those interested.”HN comment, 2021
“It makes a lot of sense having them separate. Tom Scott explains”
Tom Scott explains why separate taps make sense
It makes a lot of sense having them separate. Tom Scott explains this video Here in California showers and much other plumbing are required to have backflow valves so that hot and cold don't cross contaminate.
“Short video by Tom Scott on the subject for those interested.”
Short explanation of UK water storage tanks and separate taps
Short video by Tom Scott on the subject for those interested. this video tldw; Older homes in the UK had a water storage tank in the roof space that fed the water heating tank. This couldn't be classified as drinking water so wasn't allowed to be combined with the safe mains water that fed the cold tap. These days modern houses mostly use combi-boilers with no storage tank, so mostly both hot and cold are drinkable and it's not an issue. But preferences still lean towards the separate taps.
“you shouldn't trust drinking from the hot tap”
Explains why UK hot taps should not be drunk from
At least in Britain, if there are separate taps for hot and cold, you shouldn't trust drinking from the hot tap: this video
“the UK typically has separate taps due to the way the water is stored, or used to be stored”
Explains UK separate taps from water storage history
On the topic of mixer-taps in bathrooms, the UK typically has separate taps due to the way the water is stored, or used to be stored: this video I was pleased when I remodelled my bathroom there and installed a mixer. So much more convenient.
“See also Tom Scott's video on Britain's history with separate hot and cold taps”
History of UK separate taps and unsanitary cold water tanks
Hot water heaters frequently have sacrificial anode rods to prevent corrosion. The rods corrode over time and dissolve into the water. Lower cost aluminum rods have health concerns, not as much with magnesium rods. See also Tom Scott's video on Britain's history with separate hot and cold taps and why hot taps sometimes had unsanitary cold water tanks to supply them: this video
“Also mandatory explanation why UK historically has had 2 taps”
Explanation of why the UK historically has two taps
Mandatory Giphy: link Also mandatory explanation why UK historically has had 2 taps: this video Which in the end is understandable. It's outdated. What isn't understandable is having the light switch OUTSIDE of the friggin' restroom.
“That's because it is primarily a historical artifact[0].”
Source for historical reasons behind separate taps
That's because it is primarily a historical artifact[0]. Most modern plumbing heats water on-demand, which pretty much entirely avoids the risk of storage tank contamination or Legionella. [0]: this video
“Obligatory Tom Scott video on the topic”
Obligatory Tom Scott video on UK separate taps
Obligatory Tom Scott video on the topic: * link Bonus: "Why Britain Uses Separate Hot and Cold Taps": * this video
