1.2M views · Jan 21, 2016 · 13:12 · 1 HN recommender · 4 mentions · discussed 2019–2024
BigClive tears down a heated electric shower head of the type common in some countries, often called a suicide shower. He examines the construction and the dangerous fault conditions, such as poor insulation and missing earthing.
Why Hacker News points people here: HN commenters cite it as a teardown from a YouTuber who dissects appliances, showing live wires in contact with water.
“Big Clive also did a teardown and analysis of them, including the fault conditions that would make it dangerous”HN comment, 2024
“Big Clive also did a teardown and analysis of them, including the fault conditions that would make it dangerous”
Teardown and analysis of shower heads including dangerous fault conditions
Big Clive also did a teardown and analysis of them, including the fault conditions that would make it dangerous this video He also did one on a UK-approved unit for comparison link The units aren't dangerous if installed properly, but they're not many failures from delivering a nasty shock.
“There’s a really great YouTuber who is forever tearing domestic appliances apart”
Teardown of a heated shower head by a YouTuber who dismantles appliances
The difference is that in Scotland and Europe, it’s just one or two insulated heating elements that the water flows past. There are numerous safeties, overheat protectors, usually an RCD - in short, you’d be very unlucky to get a shock. In South America, I’ve seen two types. One: an element, but it’s uninsulated and has no safety features. This is usually operated by a water pressure switch and operates by heating a thin resistive element up. High danger of faults to earth (you’re earth). The other kind has me rather gobsmacked - the water is the element. The idea is to just pump in enough juice that the water starts to flash boil, and forms a plasma channel that then heats the surrounding water. Ostensibly safe, if earthed, but I really disliked the 60hz skin tingle - later discovered that they’d hooked earth up to the third phase in that house, when I plugged my laptop in. Metal case, leg, funky chicken. I guess the shower is reliant on skin effect to not kill you. There’s a really great YouTuber who is forever tearing domestic appliances apart - it’s actually quite amazing how some stuff is built, both in a good way and a bad way. Links to showers: link this video
BigClive teardown related to electrical safety of appliances
Electroboom did a video on the subject. It seems that they are actually safe. Not sure I'd be willing to try it though. link And bigClive this video diodeGoneWild link
“I remember this video [1] from bigclive about it.”
BigClive video showing live wires in contact with water in shower heads
I remember this video [1] from bigclive about it. I had no idea it was so common to have live wires in contact with water. At least they are grounded sometimes? [1] this video
