A UK tradesman's rant on the disadvantages of air source heat pumps, covering grants, heat pump types and whether they are worth it. He argues they are impractical for many British homes.
Why Hacker News points people here: HN uses it mostly as a contrarian or skeptical reference, with some commenters noting it glosses over details.
“Few domestic buildings in the UK have the space to install the huge and noisy air conditioning fan required”
Argues heat pumps are impractical for many UK homes.
Full comment
Few domestic buildings in the UK have the space to install the huge and noisy air conditioning fan required, never mind the insulated piping to get the heat into the house. It's a nice idea, but the reality is that most people will end up heating their water with a good old immersion heater. See this video The real problem is our buildings are badly built and insulated - and the new ones just aren't good enough.
Cites itkblevDec 2021
“Heat pumps are rather inefficient according to this video”
Claims heat pumps are inefficient.
Full comment
Heat pumps are rather inefficient according to this video [1]. Are you not bothered by all the noise it generates? Why not just use electric heater instead of a heat pump? 1 - this video
Cites itpolitelemonMar 2022
“a YouTube video explaining why heat pumps may not be so simple a solution at least in the UK”
Explains why heat pumps are not simple in the UK.
Full comment
I don't know how true this is since I'm no expert, there's a YouTube video explaining why heat pumps may not be so simple a solution at least in the UK this video Interestingly the prediction he made, regarding gas prices, did come true.
CriticalhasmaneanJul 2022
“For a video that glosses over the details but loudly proclaims this”
Full comment
For a video that glosses over the details but loudly proclaims this “ugly truth” there’s this one. I can’t tell if he is a paid shill for the gas industry or just obtuse, or maybe a voice of common sense in the wilderness…. this video
