A five-minute clip from Donald Knuth's Web of Stories interviews in which he gives advice to young people, including being wary when too many people adopt an idea.
Why Hacker News points people here: HN quotes it as a source for Knuth's caution against believing something is good just because it is trendy.
Little piece of advice from Knuth's interview playlist.
Full comment
Donald Knuth interviews are so interesting, but would like to particularly highlight this little piece of advice, out of this great playlist: "Donald Knuth - My advice to young people": this video Complete Playlist - "Donald Knuth (Computer scientist)" [97 videos]: link Also the "Oral History of Donald Knuth" from the Computer History Museum is great. "Oral History of Donald Knuth Part 1": link "Oral History of Donald Knuth Part 2": link Plus.. "Donald Knuth Interview 2006": link "An Interview with Donald Knuth": link "Interview with Donald Knuth": link This somewhat "colourful" page also tracks a few: link PS: The story that he told Steve Jobs he was "Full of shit" is not true. "Donald Knuth never told Steve Jobs that he was full of shit" link
Cites itsoveranApr 2015
“I took it from this video”
Knuth says to be wary when too many people adopt an idea.
Full comment
An extended version of the quote would be "Don't just believe that because something is trendy, that it's good. I would go the other extreme where if I find too many people adopting a certain idea I'd probably think it's wrong. Or if my work had become too popular I probably would think I have to change." I took it from this video: this video
Cites itiamcreasyJun 2015
“Source”
Knuth's advice not to believe something is good because it is trendy.
Full comment
Excellent. It's just like what Donald Knuth said, "Don't believe something is good just because it's trendy. I'd probably go the other extreme way. If I find too many people adopting a certain idea, I'd probably think its wrong." Source : this video I've always find those questions that are generally regarded as stupid party amusing. Because I think those questions showing the difference in out thought process, and instead of stigmatizing it there are valuable lessons to be learned here.
Cites itsfpotterNov 2025
“Here's another take”
Another take on getting good at something.
Full comment
Fair! Personally, I'm not sure how you can get good at something if you aren't at least a little in love with it. Here's another take: this video
