“Project Farm tested 7 penetrating oils.”
Test of 7 penetrating oils
Full comment
Project Farm tested 7 penetrating oils. ATF/Acetone ranked 2nd place above many specifically designed fluids. this video
Which Penetrating Oil is Best? Let's find out!
4.1M views · Apr 16, 2018 · 10:39 · 0 HN recommenders · 3 mentions · discussed 2020–2026
Project Farm tests six penetrating oils, including WD-40, PB Blaster, Liquid Wrench and an ATF and acetone mix, on rusted bolts. Liquid Wrench placed first and the homemade mix second.
Why Hacker News points people here: Cited as a hands-on comparison showing WD-40 is not the best penetrating oil.
“Project Farm tested 7 penetrating oils.”HN comment, 2020
What Hacker News said 3
“It's pretty decent at that[1]”
WD-40 is decent penetrating oil
Full comment
WD-40 is a penetrating oil. It's pretty decent at that[1] and not badly priced. It's a pretty "middle of the road" product at its intended purpose: displacing water and rust to loosen stuck fasteners (and other items). [1] this video
“WD-40 consistently performs worse than nearly any other available penetrating oil.”
Full comment
If it wasn't eminently obvious, most of these "secrecy" programs are marketing fluff. The actual ingredients are literally on the safety data sheet: link The company can brag that their formulation has a special blend of herbs and spices, but someone who wants to can obviously make their own special formulation and say that theirs is secret too. More importantly, the proof of the pudding is in the eating. And there is nothing particularly special about WD-40's formulation anymore. WD-40 consistently performs worse than nearly any other available penetrating oil. this video It's a terrible long term lubricant (because it's designed to evaporate, it actually concentrates gunk and grime). WD-40 themselves have come out with improved "Specialist" formulations that mostly just copy other, superior products.