Talks to Watch

Capture the Flag | He Will Not Divide Us

11.5M views · Mar 16, 2017 · 5:01 · 1 HN recommender · 5 mentions · discussed 2019–2022

Internet Historian's comedic retelling of how internet users located and captured the flag from Shia LaBeouf's He Will Not Divide Us installation, framed with Metal Gear Solid parodies. It covers the trolling campaign and the geolocation of the flag.

Why Hacker News points people here: HN refers to it as a humorous account of how online communities pinpointed the flag's location, used as an example of crowd-sourced geolocation.

“The Internet Historian on YouTube has made a series of videos about this”HN comment, 2020

What Hacker News said 5

Recommendssigwinch28Mar 2020

“The Internet Historian on YouTube has made a series of videos about this”

Internet Historian series on the HWNDU flag saga

Full comment

Yes, The Internet Historian on YouTube has made a series of videos about this: "HWNDU" (He Will Not Divide Us). It started with a flag outside in a public place [0], followed by being moved to a flagpole in the middle of nowhere (the one you're thinking of) [1]. The flag was then moved into a museum in Liverpool [2], and finally it was moved indoors with a camera pointing at a plain white painted wall [3]. Beware: lots of memes and occasionally offensive language. [0]: link [1]: this video [2]: link [3]: link

in “Finding McAfee: a case study on geoprofiling and imagery analysis” · view on HN
Cites itdavesmith1983Jul 2019

“4chan has got a lot of stuff done. Consider the HWNDU saga”

4chan found the HWNDU flag as example of effectiveness

Full comment

4chan has got a lot of stuff done. Consider the HWNDU saga: this video Obviously this is trolling, but it damn impressive they found it. They've done quite a lot of other stuff including finding ISIS targets and getting them killed, using nothing bit a sheet of paper and an innocuous message to make the media look silly, they've even caught animal abusers. Plenty of people stick their nose up to them but they are probably one of the more effective online communities. It just depends whether you happen to like what they are effective at.

in “Talk: An open-source commenting platform focused on better conversation” · view on HN
Cites itlaurent92Sep 2021

“Internet Historian is humorously documenting that it is possible to pinpoint the worldwide location of a flag”

Humorous documentation of pinpointing the flag's location

Full comment

Internet Historian is humorously documenting that it is possible to pinpoint the worldwide location of a flag with only the blue sky behind, or inside a hut lost in lapland, or inside a flat without outside light, or even a stone buried somewhere in the world (South of Spain). this video I understand it would be possible with a photo to guess which side a rock faces, thanks to the sun/shadows, and then find all the rocks pointing this way in a country using satellite image, and filtering those which are not currently at war etc.

in “Life-size camel sculptures in Saudi Arabia are older than Stonehenge, pyramids” · view on HN
Cites itverdvermJul 2022

“Reddit geolocated a flag based off a camera feed.”

Describes flag geolocated from camera feed

Full comment

Reddit geolocated a flag based off a camera feed. They used the sun and contrails to locate it iirc this video I think describes this event

in “Ask HN: Is it possible to get a location using a camera looking at Moon/Sun?” · view on HN
Cites it_dain_Dec 2022

“4channers found the flag based on the stars in the livestream, along with matching aircraft contrails to flight radar maps.”

4channers found the flag via stars and contrails

Full comment

This trick happened for real with the HWNDU stunt back in 2017. 4channers found the flag based on the stars in the livestream, along with matching aircraft contrails to flight radar maps. this video

in “Finding the B-21's hanger location from the stars in it's press image” · view on HN