Talks to Watch

The Antikythera Mechanism Episode 9 - Making The Epicyclic Pin and Slot Gearing

650K views · Oct 20, 2018 · 17:18 · 2 HN recommenders · 3 mentions · discussed 2020–2022

Clickspring makes the pin-and-slot epicyclic gearing of the Antikythera Mechanism, the module modelling the Moon's variable motion in the Greek theory, by hand.

Why Hacker News points people here: Recommended as a beautiful explanation of how the mechanism models the Moon's uneven motion.

“the video does a better job of explaining it (within the first minute)”HN comment, 2020

What Hacker News said 3

RecommendsfalcolasFeb 2020

“the video does a better job of explaining it (within the first minute)”

Shows pin-and-slot gearing modeling the moon's uneven orbital motion

Full comment

Clickspring's work on the Antikithra mechanism (and the Pateron exclusive Byzantine Sundial) is particularly interesting, because not all of the movements created by gears are circular or even. The input can be purely rotational, but the output is not. For example on the Antikithra mechanism, it has to account for the procession of the moon's orbit which causes an uneven time to complete one orbit. To properly simulate this, a pin-and-slot system is combined with an offset pivot to turn the rotation of gears into a movement that lags behind and then speeds ahead, mirroring the actual orbital period. I worded that poorly; the video does a better job of explaining it (within the first minute), and the rest of the video shows the gear train coming together this video

RecommendsutopcellJul 2021

“Perhaps the most beautiful part of the mechanism is the modelling of the motion of the Moon”

Detailed explanation of how the mechanism models the Moon's motion

Full comment

Perhaps the most beautiful part of the mechanism is the modelling of the motion of the Moon, which Chris describes in minute detail [1]. [1] this video

Cites itgus_massaMay 2022

“he makes a hole and put a small bronce in the hole”

Shows how Clickspring fixes mistakes in bronze parts

Full comment

> One wrong move and you're starting over on the entire part My guess is that it's possible to fix typos, but it would be a lot of additional work. For example to fix pieces, he makes a hole and put a small bronce in the hole, then he punch it, and then polish the surface until it's invisible. For example see this port of the previous episode this video Anyway, I'd be terrified of making a mistake if I had to do this.

in “The Antikythera Mechanism Episode 11 – Inscribing the Back Plate – Part 1” · view on HN