A University of Michigan Medicine demonstration of building a cheap DIY air purifier from a box fan and a HEPA or high-MERV filter using hardware-store parts. It explains why this helps against dust, smoke and viruses and ties it to local air quality readings.
Why Hacker News points people here: HN people link it during wildfire smoke and air quality threads as a practical, cheap fix, though a few doubt how rigorously its effectiveness was shown.
“Here's a video from the University of Michigan showing just how effective these cheap DIY air filters can be”HN comment, 2020
“Built one of those purifiers and a few days later most of my symptoms are gone.”
DIY purifier relieved commenter's allergy symptoms within days.
Full comment
If you are worried about particulate, you can build one of these: this video I built one for my room because my previous tenants had cats, which I'm allergic to. Even after steamcleaning our apartment I was chronically congested. Built one of those purifiers and a few days later most of my symptoms are gone. It's been about a month now and the filter is noticeably soiled.
RecommendsdublinbenJan 2020
“Here's a video from the University of Michigan showing just how effective these cheap DIY air filters can be”
Shows effectiveness of cheap DIY air filters.
Full comment
Here's a video from the University of Michigan showing just how effective these cheap DIY air filters can be: this video
RecommendsshardSep 2020
“I suggest building a DIY air filter, such as the one in the video here”
DIY filter for high PM2.5 from wildfires.
Full comment
If this is because of high PM2.5 concentration (due to wildfires or otherwise), I suggest building a DIY air filter, such as the one in the video here: this video When the Air Quality Index shot up to ~150 in my area (you want to keep it below 100, preferably below 50), I went to Home Depot and bought box fans and furnace filters and built my own. You can check the air quality in your area on this site: link
RecommendsQub3dSep 2020
“It won't be as good as a purpose-built machine, but it will be far better than nothing at all.”
Instructions for making a box fan and furnace filter purifier.
Full comment
The University of Michigan made an instructional video showing how you can easily make an air purifier out of a box fan and a HEPA-rated furnace filter for $25: this video It won't be as good as a purpose-built machine, but it will be far better than nothing at all. TheWirecutter found it reduced particulate matter in a room by 87%, if you do it right. They also make clear important caveats about this method -- in short, this works in a pinch, but probably should not be used in place of a purpose-built filter if you want one for year-round use. link
RecommendsthomasDec 2020
“Also, good video on all this”
Good video on DIY air filtering.
Full comment
Yeah, same thought. Something like the Coway air filter ( link ) regularly sells for under $200, and it is going to be much quieter than this option. It also has been tested fairly extensively from what I've seen, it's EnergyStar approved, etc, and it has a built in sensor. It doesn't look too bad either. But I understand the point, especially in times when you can't find a purifier. Also, good video on all this: this video
Cites itvymagueMar 2018
“But I thought it has been shown putting simple furnace filter on a fan is good enough.”
Furnace filter on a fan shown to be good enough.
Full comment
But I thought it has been shown putting simple furnace filter on a fan is good enough. this video Are you talking about other filters to filter the larger particles, and carbon filters? Because aliexpress sell them too.
Cites itmeesterdudeOct 2018
“also apparently, a box fan + filter ain't so bad.”
Box fan with filter isn't so bad.
Full comment
I know a certain framework creator that will be all over this - and has been vocal on twitter about it. I went looking, this seems like a pretty good air quality monitor: link (~$400) There are cheaper ones too; but do your research, as accuracy (and ideas about what constitutes accurate) can vary from manuf. to manuf. link also apparently, a box fan + filter ain't so bad. this video
Cites itbryceaccSep 2021
“you just put a fan filter on the back”
Fan filter design tips on airflow versus static pressure.
Full comment
this video you just put a fan filter on the back, you can increase the amount of filters to not hurt the fan motor as much by making a triangle config or fan on top of 4 filters in a cube. fans are for air throughput not static pressure so real air purifiers have squirrel cage blowers
Cites itfadyJun 2022
“Reminds me of this video that came from University of Michigan”
University of Michigan video from a California fire season.
Full comment
Reminds me of this video that came from University of Michigan during one of California's fire season when many fires were ablaze and air quality was terrible: this video
CriticalapoNov 2018
“I'm not sure I agree with the technique used to prove effectiveness”
Full comment
Nifty idea, but I'm not sure I agree with the technique used to prove effectiveness: this video The narrator puts a particle counter in front of the fan and notes the 90% reduction. So far so good. The problem is extrapolating this result to the entire room. Yes, maybe you'd get close to 90% if the device were allowed to run a few days. On the other hand, it could leave the situation worse (by blowing existing particulates around) or unimproved (by failing to filter room air efficiently enough. Either way, I'd like to see see a controlled study. Two identical rooms with identical usage. One gets a homemade filter. The other gets just a fan of the same make and model, maybe with a dummy filter to baffle airflow. What's the average particle count in both rooms after, say one week?
CriticalchewzJan 2020
“This seems like useless toy.”
Full comment
This seems like useless toy. You should be aiming for something larger that would work for an apartment. [1] this video [2] link There is thousand vidoes on Youtube on how to DYI one.
