422K views · Mar 23, 2014 · 5:15 · 4 HN recommenders · 5 mentions · discussed 2014–2025
A short Healthcare Triage episode by Aaron Carroll arguing that milk gets an undeserved pass in efforts to improve diets. It examines claims about calcium and bone strength and concludes you don't need to drink milk.
Why Hacker News points people here: Commenters link it as a concise evidence-based rebuttal to common beliefs about milk's health benefits.
“Here's a great video on the topic from one of the co-authors of this article”HN comment, 2018
“Here's a great video on the topic from one of the co-authors of this article”
Great video on the topic by a co-author of the article.
And basically no evidence that it's good for you. Here's a great video on the topic from one of the co-authors of this article: this video
“Healthcare Triage has a video on milk being not particularly healthy or even beneficial in ways people think”
Milk isn't particularly healthy or beneficial in the ways people think.
Healthcare Triage has a video on milk being not particularly healthy or even beneficial in ways people think: this video
“Here are some more details”
More details on milk's effects on calcium, sugar, and anemia.
A gallon per week by yourself, or for a household? Milk isn't inherently bad but the things you need to know are: A) Consuming it doesn't really affect your calcium levels. B) Its basically just another sugary drink. C) Excessive amounts of it can cause anemia. D) Don't give much of it to small children due to reason C. Here are some more details: this video
“I think this video is what first convinced me”
Video that first convinced commenter about milk's health impact.
I don’t think they’re quite as bad as soda, but I do think they’re fairly close. I think this video is what first convinced me (been a long time since I watched, sorry if I’m wrong about small details): this video
“Dr. Carroll regularly rails against "the milk industrial complex”
Cited as an example of Dr. Carroll railing against the milk industry.
It's definitely not settled science that you should never eat grains. Yes, some experts say you shouldn't, but if you're rejecting one expert because he disagrees with two others, it's definitely not sufficient to say it's "based on science". As for dairy, while he mentioned using butter without paranoia about fat, he didn't seem to advocate for dairy. Eating dairy might be bad, but "don't eat dairy" is bad (or ineffective) advice because _people won't follow it_. Don't make perfect the enemy of better. (If it makes you feel any better about him, Dr. Carroll regularly rails against "the milk industrial complex"[0][1][2][3].) [0] link [1] link [2] link [3] this video
