Talks to Watch

GMO Advocate Says Monsanto's Roundup Safe to Drink, Then Refuses Glass

217K views · Mar 28, 2015 · 1:40 · 0 HN recommenders · 3 mentions · discussed 2017–2021

A CBC News clip in which GMO advocate Patrick Moore claims glyphosate, the key ingredient of Monsanto's Roundup, is safe to drink, then declines when offered a glass.

Why Hacker News points people here: HN brings it up as a sardonic example of industry spokespeople not trusting their own safety claims, not as a recommendation.

What Hacker News said 3

Cites itburntrelish1273Aug 2017

“There's a video where a Monsanto lobbyist spouts circular talking-points about how glyphosate was safe to drink”

Lobbyist refuses to drink Roundup on camera.

Full comment

There's a video where a Monsanto lobbyist spouts circular talking-points about how glyphosate was safe to drink, offered either Round Up or glyphosate and refused to drink it. this video It's irrelevant if glyphosate alone is cancerous or not, because 99.9999% of deployment is via sprays like Round Up. The combined product , in both animal and human models, need thorough mutagenic research. It's just news shows don't want to give Monsanto free advertising or face libel laws, so they conflate the generic compound with the product.

in “Monsanto leaks suggest it tried to ‘kill’ cancer research about weed killer” · view on HN
CriticaljdjkckfkrrnMay 2021

“Remember when the Monsanto lobbyist/scientist said that their glyphosate pesticide Roundup is so safe you can drink it?”

Full comment

Remember when the Monsanto lobbyist/scientist said that their glyphosate pesticide Roundup is so safe you can drink it? To his surprise, he was offered a glass of it, and refused it, saying "I'm not stupid", and "I'm not an idiot", while insisting it's harmless to humans: this video How about we release this waste water in Japan's rivers, upstream of their purification plants, if it's so safe. Surely it will be thoroughly diluted by the time it ends in the tap water, below the radioactivity of a banana.

in “Scientists OK plan to release one million tonnes of waste water from Fukushima” · view on HN
Criticalrubyist5evaOct 2021

“danced around refusing to do it on the record. Good times.”

Full comment

This comment reminds of when Patrick Moore defended glyphosate and said you could drink a whole quart of it and it wouldn't hurt you - then when offered one by the reporter doing the interview danced around refusing to do it on the record. Good times. this video

in “Drug made of car exhaust filters alarms Congo's capital” · view on HN