Talks to Watch

Scottish Elevator - Voice Recognition - ELEVEN !

3.9M views · Sep 5, 2010 · 3:36 · 0 HN recommenders · 5 mentions · discussed 2019–2022

A sketch from the Scottish comedy show Burnistoun in which two men cannot get a voice-recognition elevator to understand the word eleven in their accents.

Why Hacker News points people here: Used as a joke whenever voice interfaces and accents come up, and shared as a Scottish comedy sample.

What Hacker News said 5

Cites itstevekempApr 2020

“Here's a brief sample, and another Scottish themed comedy sketch”

Sample of Scottish-themed comedy for accent practice.

Full comment

I was going to suggest something similar; listening/watching English TV which doesn't have the received-pronounciation. Other good choices would be "Yes Minister" (original series), "Fawlty Towers", and for extra-credit you should absolutely try to watch "Rab C. Nesbitt" (which is set in Glasgow. I'd suggest that Only Fools & Horses (after the second/third series) is pretty understandable to all British people, but a lot more would struggle with the Scottish accents. Here's a brief sample, and another Scottish themed comedy sketch: link this video

in “Ask HN: I’m already fluent in English. How can I improve further?” · view on HN
JokejonathankorenFeb 2019

“elevators can’t understand Scottish accents”

Full comment

Audiobooks have a very small number of accents. Often they’re recorded by middle-aged, or older men with a standard accent. (Think newscasters, and most actors) One of the advantages of CommonVoice is that breadth of voices. By having more, and different types of voices, you can build a more robust system, which works for more people. For instance, my wife is a nonnative English speaker, and had trouble for years using Siri. Alexa can’t understand small children. And of course, elevators can’t understand Scottish accents. this video

in “Mozilla releases the largest to-date public domain transcribed voice dataset” · view on HN
Jokeaidenn0May 2022

“Completely soured on the experience due to things like this[1]”

Full comment

Two reasons to resist using voice commands 1. Do not want to talk in the loud-clear voice needed for them to work (e.g. someone else in car is on their phone, kids are sleeping). 2. Completely soured on the experience due to things like this[1] 1: this video

in “The benefits of “low tech” user interfaces” · view on HN
Jokeme_smithMay 2022

“Thank you for the laugh.”

Full comment

Had to look up the skit. Thank you for the laugh. The link for those wishing to watch and skip a google search: this video

in “The benefits of “low tech” user interfaces” · view on HN
JokebambaxAug 2022

“Obligatory reference, if you haven't seen it”

Full comment

> We take a voice-first approach That sounds like a nightmare. So you have to forcibly silence everyone in the car to do anything? Even if I'm alone I would prefer silence and pushing buttons instead of having a conversation with a machine. Obligatory reference, if you haven't seen it: Scottish Elevator: this video

in “The end of the manual transmission is near?” · view on HN