Full comment
Great article! I particularly like this paragraph: >It’s important to note that while the charge equalization process is fast, the drift of individual electrons is not. The field propagates at close to the speed of light in vacuum (circa 300,000 km/s); individual electrons in a copper wire typically slither at speeds measured in centimeters per hour or less. A crude analogy is the travel of sound waves in air: if you yell at someone, they will hear you long before any single air molecule makes it from here to there. So basically electricity flows like a Newton's cradle. But this leaves one nagging question: what is the nature of the delay? This question also arises when considering the microscopic cause of index-of-refraction for light[1]. If you take a simple atom, like hydrogen, and shine a light on it of a particular frequency, I understand that the electron will jump to a higher energy energy level, and then fall back down. But what governs the delay between these jumps? And also, how is it that, in general, light will continue propagating in the same direction? That is, there seems to be some state-erasure or else the electron would have to "remember" more details about the photon that excited it. (And who knows? Maybe the electron does "remember" the incident photon through some sort of distortion of the quantum field which governs the electron's motion.) The same question applies to electron flow - what are the parameters that determine the speed of electricity in a co
