Talks to Watch

PHILOSOPHY - Michel Foucault

4M views · Jul 3, 2015 · 8:17 · 2 HN recommenders · 3 mentions · discussed 2018–2021

A School of Life short introducing Michel Foucault, who questioned assumed progress in how society treats madness, medicine and sexuality.

Why Hacker News points people here: HN recommends it as a simple entry point to Foucault, especially on mental health and institutionalization.

“I recommend you watch the following video on Foucault”HN comment, 2021

What Hacker News said 3

RecommendsjadedhackerMay 2018

“He was a radical philosopher that discussed the treatment of mental health”

Introduction to Foucault's views on mental health and institutionalization.

Full comment

Yes and no. Check out Foucault. He was a radical philosopher that discussed the treatment of mental health and was a critic of institutionalization. I don't know enough about him to agree or disagree with him, but he is an influential point of view. this video

in “American society increasingly mistakes intelligence for human worth (2016)” · view on HN
RecommendsyurieltJan 2021

“I recommend you watch the following video on Foucault”

Simplified intro to Foucault on how society treats the mentally ill.

Full comment

And this is quite honestly a good things. Wait before you downvote. Hear me out the current system is horrible and what it determines as insane people is a product of such system. Back in the Middle Ages when we had a different approach to mental health non neurotypical people were regarded as different, yes but not as garbage or plainly wrong just because of being odd. Instead in some cases they were even regarded as wise as a result of this. Think about alchemy for example something like that could only have been tried by very very mentally ill people and if they weren’t so at the beginning their handling of mercury sure made them crazy after a while. Modern society easily ditched the mentally ill. However they can give a lot and if that makes a couple companies in the internet mad so be it. I recommend you watch the following video on Foucault this video it is an over simplification but it will help you understand. I also recommend reading the anti edipous from Delouse and Guatari to get an insight in how the current system hides and destroys the mentally ill in spite of how much they have given to history and humanity. The truth is without mentally ill a people society would be different and thus anti mentally ill sentiment of modernity is but a depravity as non neurotypical variations are for memes(social culture and the academia for example) what mutation is for genes

in “Most of what you read on the internet is written by insane people (2018)” · view on HN
Cites itrgiffordJun 2021

“Michael Foucalt has better arguments to make here than I do”

Cited for Foucault's arguments on social progress.

Full comment

> ...we should think about how we can help more people become successful. It's like you're purposefully missing the point. What if most of serious wealth and success is decided at birth? What are the logical consequences of that? Let's go extreme: A rich guy wins the lottery. He then tells everyone in town how they could've won if they bought tickets. What's your reaction? > Even poor people today live better than kings in the past. I generally agree with this on quantitative measures of productive or technological progress. Other quantitative measures don't look so great: education, housing and healthcare costs; health (esp. mental health) issues in developed vs developing nations; prison populations in the present vs past. Michael Foucalt has better arguments to make here than I do [1]. 1. this video