Talks to Watch

How does a whip break the sound barrier? (Slow Motion Shockwave formation) - Smarter Every Day 207

6.5M views · Dec 28, 2018 · 11:21 · 2 HN recommenders · 3 mentions · discussed 2019–2023

Smarter Every Day uses high-speed and Schlieren photography to show how a whip crack is a supersonic shockwave formed at the tip. It references academic papers on whip physics.

Why Hacker News points people here: Recommended as the clearest footage of a whip tip going supersonic, and cited in shockwave discussions.

“I highly recommend it.”HN comment, 2019

What Hacker News said 3

Strongly recommendswolfram74Mar 2019

“I highly recommend it.”

Old-school Schlieren setup capturing shockwave formation in whip cracks.

Full comment

As mentioned by others, the photography technique looks like (and apparently is a software enabled variant of) Schlieren photography. This(1) is a neat example of an old school Schlieren set up capturing shockwave formation during whip cracks. I highly recommend it. (1) this video

in “Nasa captures images of supersonic shockwaves” · view on HN
Strongly recommendsnuccyDec 2021

“(very much recommended)”

Shows a whip tip reaching supersonic speed.

Full comment

Fun fact, you can accelerate an almost-everyday object to supersonic speeds: whip tip [1,2]. 1. link 2. this video (very much recommended)

Cites itmaxbondApr 2023

“you can observe this effect in the high speed Schlieren footage of a whip in this video”

High speed Schlieren footage illustrating shockwave overtaking disturbance.

Full comment

Point taken. Thanks for the explanation, that helped me a achieve a deeper understanding & blew my mind. This animation of a tachyon goes well with your explanation: link If you look for it, you can observe this effect in the high speed Schlieren footage of a whip in this video this video (you can skip to around 8 minutes) It starts to disturb the air, then the shockwave overtakes the disturbance, so you can observe them in the flipped order if you're in the sound universe.

in “Sabine Hossenfelder: I think faster than light travel is possible. Here's why” · view on HN