Cites itcwrichardkimJan 2024“I think the interesting bit here is actually the teachable mode (19:30 in the vid)”
Rabbit r1 keynote showing teachable mode for agents
Full comment
I think the interesting bit here is actually the teachable mode (19:30 in the vid): this video there are tools that exist that teach agents what to do, but the ability to have them on command and return a nice little summary in a neat UI is actually kind of compelling. It also feeds the company routine information to fine tune agents and maybe results in a dev ecosystem of some kind? need to learn more about how the system prevents some of the concerns hear like taking undesirable actions on your behalf
“It's the most blatantly fake product demo I have ever seen.”
Full comment
Their "keynote" just screams shenanigans. It's the most blatantly fake product demo I have ever seen. To take one example, at 14m30s, the CEO is shown using the device to book a trip to London. This is presented as a live demo, but it's clearly simulated. this video
“But the spreadsheet it sent, that they then show on screen, has not filtered any candidates to LA-only.”
Full comment
Fun tidbit: There's a point in the tech demo where he asks the rabbit device to "filter job candidates to ones that are LA-based" When the r1 address replies to him, it attaches a new spreadsheet, and he opens it on-stage. But the spreadsheet it sent, that they then show on screen, has not filtered any candidates to LA-only. (The column next to their names shows labels on screen like "NYC", "Austin", "Miami", "Seattle", etc) this video (exact timestamp)
“my view (and I understand how plugins, LLM, AI and other related things work) ist thre are no LAM in the rabbit r1.”
Full comment
Maybe you should watch their announcement video again: this video Or the interview of the CEO, Jesse Lyu aboutn the LAM: link If you're still sure that the LAM is present in their product, that's fine, but my view (and I understand how plugins, LLM, AI and other related things work) ist thre are no LAM in the rabbit r1.
“You really have to watch the Steve Jobs-esque announcement video to understand what they were promising with this device”
Full comment
You really have to watch the Steve Jobs-esque announcement video to understand what they were promising with this device, and understand how utterly it failed to deliver on those promises. this video
“This whole thing was faked yet it was presented as a live demonstration, not an illustration.”
Full comment
If you pre-record your live demo then it isn't a live demo... What I dislike is presenting something as if it is live when it isn't. Demos are fantastic things and it is even perfectly fine to have imaginative aspects to them. But there's a division line between demoing and lying. Take Rabbit R1 as an example[0]. This whole thing was faked yet it was presented as a live demonstration, not an illustration. In other words, fraud. The difference is if you're trying to show your customers (or potential customers) what you're imagining the device works like vs what the device actually works like. The difference is how you're communicating the difference to them. I'm not sure why this is a contentious opinion, but just don't lie to people? [0] this video
