Talks to Watch

Smarter than a Smart TV! (Raspberry Pi Inside)

2.4M views · Jun 8, 2022 · 9:10 · 2 HN recommenders · 6 mentions · discussed 2022–2023

Jeff Geerling looks at a Sharp NEC commercial display with a slot for a Raspberry Pi Compute Module. It is a large screen without built-in smart TV features or tracking.

Why Hacker News points people here: Brought up in smart TV complaint threads as a real-world 'dumb display' alternative.

“Jeff Geerling talks about how great a TV his non-TV is.”HN comment, 2023

What Hacker News said 6

RecommendsarararJan 2023

“Jeff Geerling talks about how great a TV his non-TV is.”

Geerling uses a professional NEC display instead of a smart TV.

Full comment

Just get a "display". See this video where Jeff Geerling talks about how great a TV his non-TV is. He has an NEC UHD Professional Display M551. He gets to control the software on the embedded Raspberry Pi. It's about $1700 but I think it's worth it. Product link link

RecommendsmodrianoMar 2023

“A recent Jeff Geerling video dug into this subject.”

Covers Sharp NEC business displays without smart features.

Full comment

A recent Jeff Geerling video dug into this subject. [0]. Sharp NEC [1] makes and sells TVs without any "smart" junk (they're mainly aimed at being 24/7 monitors/displays in businesses). They're significantly more expensive than consumer TVs, but part of that is likely to accommodate 24/7 usage. [0] this video [1] link

in “Streaming company Roku to lay off 6% workforce” · view on HN
Cites itsaxonwwAug 2022

“Jeff Geerling did a video on an interesting one from Sharp/NEC that takes a smart module”

Geerling reviews a commercial NEC display with an insertable Raspberry Pi.

Full comment

This comes up over and over again. There is a brand that sells through Wal Mart in the US (Sceptre) which tends to not have smart features. They are not high end sets. You can also get 'commercial' sets intended for signage that are apparently OK too. Jeff Geerling did a video on an interesting one from Sharp/NEC that takes a smart module, which can be a raspberry pi, here: this video . There are some caveats, but it's something to keep an eye on IMO. It seems to be true that there are no high end/aspirational sets that don't have smart features. I haven't personally seen any OLEDs, for example (although I am not an authority on this).

in “GM makes $1,500 subscription mandatory on GMC, Buick, Cadillac Models” · view on HN
Cites itjamesbfbAug 2022

“Jeff Geerling talks about this very TV in one of his videos a while back”

Geerling covers this non-smart display with a Raspberry Pi inside.

Full comment

Jeff Geerling talks about this very TV in one of his videos a while back: this video If my partner wasn’t so hell bent in decor when choosing a TV, I would have loved one of these!

in “The downfall of smart TVs: From promises of seamless viewing to ad tool” · view on HN
Cites itantongribokSep 2022

“there's a review of it from Jeff Geerling”

Geerling's review of a TV with a built-in Raspberry Pi.

Full comment

The fact that it actually comes with a Raspberry Pi is incredibly cool to me. Oh, and of course there's a review of it from Jeff Geerling: this video Actually, this thing has some pretty decent specs... my initial reaction was that it was overpriced, but now I'm thinking this is a decent deal for what you get.

Cites itgclawesApr 2023

“It would be so cool if it supported something like an insertable Raspberry Pi like these NEC displays did”

NEC displays accept an insertable Raspberry Pi.

Full comment

It would be so cool if it supported something like an insertable Raspberry Pi like these NEC displays did, but with standard consumer TV display characteristics (4k, > 60hz, etc) this video

in “Ask Wirecutter: Can You Recommend a Not-Smart TV for Me?” · view on HN