Talks to Watch

Building a Marsbase is a Horrible Idea: Let’s do it!

21.9M views · Feb 3, 2019 · 7:56 · 4 HN recommenders · 5 mentions · discussed 2019–2024

A Kurzgesagt animation walking through how a Mars base could be built and why it would be punishing, covering radiation, temperature extremes, toxic dust and the need for shielding.

Why Hacker News points people here: Recommended as a sobering, accessible overview of the practical challenges of living on Mars.

“sobering run down of the realities when living on mars”HN comment, 2019

What Hacker News said 5

RecommendsgtsteveMar 2019

“Perhaps watch this video for a nice overview of what that might look like”

Overview of what a Mars base would look like and its problems.

Full comment

Perhaps watch this video for a nice overview of what that might look like: this video I think you'll probably see baby steps towards it but there are a lot of problems to overcome.

in “Ask HN: I am 33 yrs young, will we form a colony in Mars within my lifetime?” · view on HN
RecommendsabledonJun 2019

“sobering run down of the realities when living on mars”

Sobering rundown of realities of living on Mars, like soil shielding.

Full comment

sobering run down of the realities when living on mars: this video The layers of soil we'd have to cover our buildings in really got me!

in “Four Mars missions are launching next year” · view on HN
RecommendsEtheryteApr 2021

“Kurzgesagt has a great video outlining many of the challenges [0].”

Outlines challenges of inhabiting Mars: radiation, temperature, microdust.

Full comment

There is no sugarcoating it, Mars is a hostile environment and to claim otherwise would simply be lying. Between the radiation, temperature, microdust and more, inhabiting Mars will be very hard. Kurzgesagt has a great video outlining many of the challenges [0]. Regardless of how meticulously you prepare, mistakes on Mars will lead to death and it's good to be honest and upfront about it. [0] this video

in “Elon Musk on Mars efforts: “A bunch of people will probably die.”” · view on HN
RecommendsnotTooFarGoneJun 2024

“Nice kurzgesagt video”

Explains radiation and sustainability difficulties of a Mars colony.

Full comment

I think you vastly underestimate the amount of radiation and how hard it would be to build a colony that is protected enough and is "self sustaining". Nice kurzgesagt video: this video If we manage to terraform mostly using robots and bacteria that would be so much easier.

in “Why Nothing Can Grow on Mars” · view on HN
Cites itchriskananFeb 2019

“Mars to Stay is a legitimate idea and makes a lot of sense for colonization”

Full comment

So many comments here are really depressing and lack a sense of adventure and romance. Yes, Mars One did not have a sound plan, but it inspired a certain kind of person who wants a grand adventure with impact. Mars to Stay is a legitimate idea and makes a lot of sense for colonization: link The Mars One idea of turning the colonists life into a reality TV show would be the first reality TV show I'd ever want to watch and would make a fantastic documentary. So, while Mars One was severely flawed, I think the Mars to Stay philosophy makes a lot of sense if we want to colonize Mars. this video

in “Mars One, which offered 1-way trips to Mars, declared bankrupt” · view on HN