Talks to Watch

The Hobbit: A Long-Expected Autopsy (Part 1/2)

5.9M views · Mar 28, 2018 · 36:49 · 3 HN recommenders · 3 mentions · discussed 2019–2022

The first part of Lindsay Ellis's video essay series on the troubled production and critical reception of The Hobbit film trilogy.

Why Hacker News points people here: HN recommends it as an engaging analysis of how the Hobbit films were made, in threads on CGI and Tolkien.

“Lindsay Ellis has a three-part video essay series”HN comment, 2022

What Hacker News said 3

Strongly recommendsmuzzioSep 2019

“Lindsay Ellis has some great film/TV analysis videos.”

Postmortem on the Hobbit films, a Hugo nominee.

Full comment

Longer form than EFaP, but Lindsay Ellis has some great film/TV analysis videos. She's usually more focused on writing than anything else, though. Here's a postmortem she did on the Hobbit films, which was recently nominated for a Hugo award: this video Other solid works by her include a postmortem on the last season of Game of Thrones and an analysis of themes in Michael Bay's Transformers. (I know that last one sounds weird, but it's really well done.)

in “Postmortem: Every Frame a Painting (2017)” · view on HN
RecommendsApocryphonJan 2020

“Here's the first video in a small YouTube series on it”

Series on the Hobbit films' troubled production.

Full comment

The Hobbit films had a troubled production and were terribly rushed. Here's the first video in a small YouTube series on it: this video

in “Christopher Tolkien has died” · view on HN
Recommendsscott_sFeb 2022

“Lindsay Ellis has a three-part video essay series”

Video essay series on how the Hobbit films were made.

Full comment

Agreed agreed. The problem with The Hobbit was not the visual effects. The problem was that it was made without a plan, under duress. Lindsay Ellis has a three-part video essay series ( this video yes, I know it says 1/2, I promise there is a 2/3) exploring this.

in “Over-reliance on CGI in movies” · view on HN