Talks to Watch

Germany is 'totally controlled' by Russia, Trump says | Squawk Box Europe

192K views · Jul 11, 2018 · 5:01 · 0 HN recommenders · 3 mentions · discussed 2022–2025

A short CNBC clip from 2018 in which President Trump criticizes Germany for paying billions of dollars to Russia for energy, saying Germany is 'totally controlled' by Russia. It comes from a NATO summit news segment.

Why Hacker News points people here: Cited in later threads on Russian gas dependence as an example of Trump's 2018 warning to Germany that proved prescient.

“warning about German dependence on Russian gas”HN comment, 2025

What Hacker News said 3

Cites itblibbleNov 2022

Trump remarks on German dependence on Russian gas.

Full comment

ah yes, it's the US fault the corrupt German politicians made Germany entirely dependent on Russian gas even Trump understood this was a stupid idea: this video

in “Europe accuses US of profiting from war” · view on HN
Cites itrs999gtiJan 2025

2018 warning about German dependence on Russian oil and gas.

Full comment

> It's been a big issue for western european countries during the ukraine war. In 2018, Germany (and France) were warned about their dependence and deals with Russia on oil and gas - this video

in “Ask HN: Is wind power financially viable without subsidies?” · view on HN
Cites it0xDEAFBEADMar 2025

“warning about German dependence on Russian gas”

Trump in 2018 warning Germany about Russian gas dependence.

Full comment

I don't support Trump, but you really can't claim that Europe wasn't warned here. Russia first invaded Ukraine back in 2014. And here's Trump back in 2018, warning about German dependence on Russian gas, and stating that Europe needed to step up defense spending "immediately": this video This has hardly been "abrupt". Even Obama and Bush were telling Europe to step up defense spending.

in “Millions are visiting the European Alternatives site. What trends are we seeing?” · view on HN