Joscha Bach's 35C3 talk offers an AI perspective on the soul, covering perception, mental representation, agency, consciousness and selfhood as things that can arise in a computational system like the brain.
Why Hacker News points people here: HN commenters call it lucid and fluff-free, and point to Bach as one of the most interesting voices on AI, consciousness and philosophy.
“the whole talk is incredibly lucid and contains zero fluff or BS”HN comment, 2020
“the whole talk is incredibly lucid and contains zero fluff or BS”
Dense, lucid argument that computation supports conscious thought
Full comment
Yesterday I watched a fascinating talk The Ghost in the Machine by AI researcher Josha Bach. He claims that computational math is enough to support the conscious thought, both in living things and simulated environments. The whole talk is densely packed with ideas and concepts (for example nice illustration of concepts behind back-propagation NNs at 19:20). Here [0] he lays out his current model for mind. I have no idea what to make of it, but the whole talk is incredibly lucid and contains zero fluff or BS (unlike linked article). [0] this video
RecommendsfjfaaseJan 2020
“Joscha Bach has an interesting take on how to combine idealism with materalism.”
Interesting take combining idealism with materialism
Full comment
Joscha Bach has an interesting take on how to combine idealism with materalism. See for example his 'The Ghost in the Machine' talk at 35C3: this video
Recommendsmaze-leJul 2020
“He is definitely one of the most interesting people to listen to when it comes to AI, Intelligence and Philosophy.”
One of several Bach talks on AI and philosophy
Full comment
He is definitely one of the most interesting people to listen to when it comes to AI, Intelligence and Philosophy. I've seen him in Leipzig on CCC events in the past, here are some of his other talks: * Computational Meta-Intelligence (32C3): link * Machine Dreams (33C3): link * The Ghost in the Machine (35C3): this video He also did a very interesting podcast episode with Fefe and Frank from alternativlos! (in German): link
Cites itfjfaaseJul 2023
“With respect to consciousness, Joshua Bach has an interesting view”
Bach's interesting view on consciousness
Full comment
I also believe that in order to make progress it is important to accept those things that are established as scientific fact even if they counter intuitive or hard to accept. With respect to consciousness, Joshua Bach has an interesting view: this video
