1.3M views · May 7, 2020 · 15:07 · 3 HN recommenders · 4 mentions · discussed 2021
Andrew Huang explains the harmonic series, which he calls the foundation of almost all music. He builds the idea up step by step, with demonstrations of overtones and how harmonies derive from them.
Why Hacker News points people here: HN recommends it as a clear, short but in-depth explanation of harmonics and overtones, useful even for musicians.
“Music producer Andrew Huang does a fantastic job demonstrating the harmonic series concepts”HN comment, 2021
“Music producer Andrew Huang does a fantastic job demonstrating the harmonic series concepts”
Fantastic demonstration of the harmonic series
Music producer Andrew Huang does a fantastic job demonstrating the harmonic series concepts in a video from last year: this video
“Andrew Huang does a good job of explaining harmonics and overtones”
Clear explanation of harmonics, overtones, and sonograms
Andrew Huang does a good job of explaining harmonics and overtones[0]. You only need to watch until about the 4 minute mark (from the timestamp) to get an explanation of harmonics and what the sonograms represent. The short of it is that most natural sounds product a root tone plus a varying amount of related tones above it. Our ears hear the root tone, and the other tones above it are what give the sound its uniqueness. That's why a guitar, a clarinet and 3 singers can produce the same note while sounding distinct. Birds seem to produce a natural sound without a lot of the related tones above it. Their sound is, relatively speaking, much purer than most other natural sounds. That's very unique. [0]: this video
“This video does a good job of explaining it in a relatively short and simple way”
Short, simple but in-depth harmonic series explanation, even for musicians
The harmonic series is a really neat thing to learn about -- one of those "art is math" kind of moments. This video does a good job of explaining it in a relatively short and simple way, but goes in-depth enough that even people with an understanding of music might learn something: this video
“a lot of harmonies are built on top of the harmonic series.”
Harmonies built on harmonic series
Well, a lot of harmonies are built on top of the harmonic series. See this video And tuning is all about 'numerical puns', similar to how eg 2^10 ~ 10^3, but for perfect fifths and octaves etc. Of course, our physiology and culture is a bit too complicated and convoluted to understand everything about music from first principles like this. So most of the time you are better off learning (and treating) music as music instead of as applied math or physics.
