Talks to Watch

Tool-Making Crows

942K views · Sep 9, 2006 · 0:41 · 0 HN recommenders · 3 mentions · discussed 2009–2016

A one-minute clip of the New Caledonian crow Betty bending a straight wire into a hook to retrieve food from a tube. It comes from a 2002 Science study on tool-making in crows.

Why Hacker News points people here: HN links it as the clearest demonstration that crows can fashion tools.

“A crow, given food in a thin cylinder and a piece of wire, bends the wire into a hook and pulls the food out.”HN comment, 2009

What Hacker News said 3

Cites itbrandenAug 2009

“A crow, given food in a thin cylinder and a piece of wire, bends the wire into a hook and pulls the food out.”

Crow bends wire into hook to retrieve food.

Full comment

Similar: this video A crow, given food in a thin cylinder and a piece of wire, bends the wire into a hook and pulls the food out.

in “Aesop Was Right: Birds Use Rocks to Raise Water Level” · view on HN
Cites itquadrangleFeb 2015

“Perhaps you don't understand that crows use tools.”

Shows crows using tools

Full comment

bullshit. Perhaps you don't understand that crows use tools. this video and that they also are social and communicate with each other. They do give gifts to each other as part of courtship. We don't need to anthropomorphize to recognize plain facts about crows being intelligent and intentional and social.

in “A girl who gets gifts from birds” · view on HN
Cites itabruzziJul 2016

“Specifically, bending a wire into a hook to retrieve food”

Crow bends a wire into a hook to retrieve food

Full comment

This is not nearly as complex a sequence, but has a bit of tool making. Specifically, bending a wire into a hook to retrieve food: this video

in “When a crow dies, the other crows investigate the cause of death (2015)” · view on HN