Talks to Watch

Can You Trust Kurzgesagt Videos?

7.1M views · Mar 3, 2019 · 6:10 · 0 HN recommenders · 3 mentions · discussed 2020–2022

Kurzgesagt addresses whether viewers can trust its videos, describing its research process and how it handles older videos with errors or overstated claims.

Why Hacker News points people here: HN cites it when debating Kurzgesagt's credibility and its corrections and removals of earlier content.

“They also vet their videos with experts and are transparent in their methodology”HN comment, 2020

What Hacker News said 3

Cites itCaptArmchairSep 2020

“They also vet their videos with experts and are transparent in their methodology”

Kurzgesagt's transparent vetting methodology cited to defend its credibility.

Full comment

> I think this explanation, as well as that from the video, is layman psychology at best Well, kurzgesagt back their statements with references to academic research: link They also vet their videos with experts and are transparent in their methodology: this video > Yes, there are factors or mechanisms that drive your desire for belonging, but it is a pretty unconvincing observation. It doesn't have to be tribalism to prefer being around people you trust. Why would you assume that I didn't consider other explanations? > FOMO is more connected to the fear of the unknown and fear of loss in my opinion. In what way wouldn't "the fear of the unkown" or "the fear of loss" be less connected with the fear of likely missing crucial parts of the conversations your social network is having? e.g. you might miss out hearing about a party, where someone makes an personal announcement (e.g. getting married, moving to another country,...). So, now your friends have a shared experience of having heard the news first hand that you aren't part of. > A "tribe" would shield you of course, but it is mostly a sign of other needs not being met. Advertisers use it to their advantage for decades. Some appeal to their audiences to be the source of other peoples FOMOs. "think different" instead of "stay connected". What "other needs" are these? > There are less suicides than in the 90s. How is the number of suicides 30 years ago relevant to a dynamic observed over the course of the past 15 years? > That

Cites itirjustinMar 2022

“the basically walked it back from such a hard line stance in a correction/update video[1]”

Kurzgesagt's correction video softening its earlier stance on addiction.

Full comment

> physical vs psychological dependence is kind of outdated I wouldn't say outdated, but I do agree it is 100% up for debate. Kurzgesagt did a really similar video[0] on addiction, but the basically walked it back from such a hard line stance in a correction/update video[1]. It's not so easy to tease apart the social vs the physical vs the pure mental. > Just the same, you can be addicted to coffee. Caffeine is a drug. Right, I think you're agreeing with me. That they have similar aspects, but to treat them the same - like putting caffine on Class 1 - would be insane. [0] link [1] this video

in “My lizard brain is no match for infinite scroll” · view on HN
Cites itDextroMay 2022

“They also removed a few of their older videos at the time”

Kurzgesagt addresses presenting uncertain things as fact.

Full comment

I believe they did it on this video called "Can You Trust Kurzgesagt?". They also removed a few of their older videos at the time because they had this exact issue of presenting as fact some things that were not at all certain. this video