Talks to Watch

Rupert Sheldrake - The Science Delusion BANNED TED TALK

2M views · Mar 15, 2013 · 18:20 · 2 HN recommenders · 3 mentions · discussed 2013–2022

A re-upload of Rupert Sheldrake's TEDx talk The Science Delusion, which TED removed from its channel. He challenges what he calls the dogmas of modern science, including whether fundamental constants are constant.

Why Hacker News points people here: Recommended by some as a provocative critique of scientific dogma, and also cited as the talk TED pulled.

“his points about fundamental "constants" changing, and the metrologists' dogmatic (really, anti-scientific) response, are worth pondering.”HN comment, 2017

What Hacker News said 3

RecommendstokenizerDec 2013

“Rupert Sheldrake had a great TED talk on the dogma's of modern science”

Sheldrake TED talk on dogmas of modern science

Full comment

I think this shows scientific institutions and advocates in a bad light. Rupert Sheldrake had a great TED talk on the dogma's of modern science, and was even further legitimized when a private council of TED banned the talk. Link: this video

in “Reddit’s science forum banned climate deniers. Why don’t all newspapers?” · view on HN
RecommendscprJul 2017

“his points about fundamental "constants" changing, and the metrologists' dogmatic (really, anti-scientific) response, are worth pondering.”

Sheldrake on changing fundamental constants

Full comment

An interesting (banned) TEDx talk by Rupert Sheldrake, one part on the changing "fundamental constants", starting here: this video The other parts are a bit "woo" and I'm sure would be laughed at by the HN crowd. But his points about fundamental "constants" changing, and the metrologists' dogmatic (really, anti-scientific) response, are worth pondering.

in “NIST to redefine the kilogram based on a fundamental universal constant” · view on HN
Cites itameliusJan 2022

“then later he gave a talk called "The Science Delusion" which got banned from TED”

Sheldrake talk banned from TED

Full comment

Reminds me of a talk of Rupert Sheldrake at Google Talks: link and then later he gave a talk called "The Science Delusion" which got banned from TED: this video

in “The control group is out of control (2014)” · view on HN