Talks to Watch

[60 fps] The Flying Train, Germany, 1902

2.8M views · Aug 9, 2020 · 3:48 · 2 HN recommenders · 4 mentions · discussed 2020–2023

Neural-network upscaled, 60 fps, stabilized and colorized version of 1902 footage of the Wuppertal Schwebebahn suspended railway in Germany. The source film comes from MoMA. It gives a vivid view of an early-1900s city and a train system that still runs.

Why Hacker News points people here: HN commenters share it as a favorite example of upscaled vintage footage that makes the early 1900s feel present, though some find the colorization off.

“I've really come to enjoy these sorts of upscaled videos that allow a view of various cities in the early 1900's.”HN comment, 2021

What Hacker News said 4

Strongly recommendspetefordeDec 2023

“My personal favorite is”

Favorite upscaled vintage short, loved by commenter's family

Full comment

I'm not a film expert, but I like to think I have taste? And yet, somehow the recent Beatles projects reduced me to tears on several occasions. Am I secretly a chud in denial, or are my tastes just offensive? Look, everyone has the right to be an elitist on their own film blog. The author didn't ask us to read what he said. However, his entire thesis is dramatically undermined by the simple fact that he didn't attempt to grab even a single comparison frame from the original releases so that a reader can A/B them and make up their minds for themselves. As to his distaste for those upscaled and colorized vintage shorts, I'm happy to go on record and say that I love them. In fact, watching these clips is the closest thing my family has to a Christmas tradition at this point. My personal favorite is this video and frankly, I don't have the time of day for anyone who is upset that I think it's wonderful.

in “They want you to forget what a film looks like” · view on HN
RecommendsGeekyBearOct 2021

“I've really come to enjoy these sorts of upscaled videos that allow a view of various cities in the early 1900's.”

Upscaled early-1900s footage of Wuppertal, Germany

Full comment

I've really come to enjoy these sorts of upscaled videos that allow a view of various cities in the early 1900's. New York: link San Francisco: link Paris: link Wuppertal, Germany: this video

in “The Hindenburg disaster denoised, upscaled, and colorized using ML [video]” · view on HN
Cites itAnimatsAug 2020

“The 4K upgraded version, with good speed correction and somewhat lame colorization.”

4K upgraded version of the 1902 flying train footage

Full comment

The 4K upgraded version, with good speed correction and somewhat lame colorization.[1] Here's a cab ride today, from the back end.[2] [1] this video [2] link

in “Ride through Wuppertal on ‘the flying train’ in clear footage from 1902” · view on HN
CriticalAnimatsOct 2020

“The colors are all wrong.”

Full comment

That colorized well, or seemed to, since the original had little color. It had to color "building", "snow", and "skin". That's about it. Here, though, is a similar technique applied to the Wuppertal monorail.[1] The colors are all wrong. The supports was really lime green, the overhead track was brown, and the carriages were a glossy red. Since the training set lacks data for 19th century supported monorails, it's just guessing. [1] this video

in “Colorized and upscaled footage of a snowball fight filmed in 1896” · view on HN