139K views · Sep 15, 2021 · 2:52:56 · 3 HN recommenders · 5 mentions · discussed 2021–2023
Lex Fridman interviews Douglas Lenat, founder of Cyc, a decades-long project to encode common-sense knowledge and reasoning for AI. They discuss symbolic AI and how it may complement neural networks.
Why Hacker News points people here: Pointed to as the long-form interview for understanding Lenat's work, especially after his death.
“If anybody wants to hear more about Doug's work and ideas, here is a (fairly long) interview with Doug by Lex Fridman”HN comment, 2023
“I thought that Douglas Lenat's remarks (at Lex Fridman's podcast) about this were really insightful”
Lenat's remarks judged really insightful on the topic.
I thought that Douglas Lenat's remarks (at Lex Fridman's podcast) about this were really insightful[1]. [1] this video
“If anybody wants to hear more about Doug's work and ideas, here is a (fairly long) interview with Doug by Lex Fridman”
Long interview to learn more about Lenat's work and ideas.
If anybody wants to hear more about Doug's work and ideas, here is a (fairly long) interview with Doug by Lex Fridman, from last year. this video
“Lenat thought CYC and neural nets could be complementary”
Lenat on Cyc and neural nets being complementary kinds of thinking.
There's an interesting (& long!) recent Lex Fridman interview with Doug Lenat here: this video Lenat thought CYC and neural nets could be complementary, with neural nets providing right brain/fast thinking capability, and CYC left brain/slow (analytic/reflective) thinking capability. It's odd to see Lenat discuss CYC the way he does - as if 40 years on everything was still going well despite it having dropped off the public radar twenty years ago.
“I've been thinking a lot about this interview on Cyc”
Interview on Cyc and symbolic common sense for AI.
I do wonder if we'll see the rise of symbolic AI to give deep learning a sense of common sense? I've been thinking a lot about this interview on Cyc: this video
“There's also a lengthy Lex Fridman interview with Doug Lenat, from just a year ago”
Cited as lengthy Lenat interview from a year earlier.
I'll admit it was news to me that Cycorp is still around! There's an interesting thread here that provides some insight from former/current employees into what they are actually doing nowadays. link There's also a lengthy Lex Fridman interview with Doug Lenat, from just a year ago, here: this video It seems as if the "common sense expert system" foundation of CYC (the mostly unstated common knowledge behind all human communication) was basically completed, but what has failed to materialize is any higher level comprehensive knowledge base and reasoning system (i.e some form of AGI) based on top of this. It's not clear from the outside whether anyone working at Cycorp still really believes there is a CYC-based path to AGI, but regardless it seems not to be something that's really being funded and worked on, and 40 years on probably fair to say it's not going to happen. It seems that Cycorp stays alive by selling the hype and winning contracts to develop domain-specific expert systems, based on the CYC methodology and toolset, that really have little reliance on the "common sense" foundations they are nominally built on top of.
