Talks to Watch

Why American public transit is so bad | 2020 Election

6.7M views · Oct 22, 2020 · 9:40 · 1 HN recommender · 3 mentions · discussed 2021–2023

A Vox explainer from the 2020 election series on why American public transit is so poor. It traces the effect of the interstate highway system on cities and the resulting car dependence.

Why Hacker News points people here: Linked in transit and infrastructure threads as a general explanation, with one commenter drawing the point that good transit depends on networks.

“good transit is about networks”HN comment, 2021

What Hacker News said 3

Recommendsthrow0101aMar 2021

“good transit is about networks”

Shows good transit depends on networks, not isolated routes.

Full comment

> IMO streetcars in general are a pretty bad investment, as they are generally just a way of making a bus, but more expensive and stuck on rails. The value of a streetcar or a bus depends on the volume of passengers that are served. The more people, the more a streetcar (maybe) makes sense. At some point you have so many buses and so many drives (salaries, benefits, 401k/pensions) that the main cost on the line becomes people and not equipment. (More buses also need more mechanics, etc.) There is a range of average daily ridership where buses, bus rapid transit (single/double lanes), light rail, and heavy rail each make sense. * link One should also keep in mind that good transit is about networks : a random route here or there is not useful. Vox made a video outlining this: * this video * link

in “So You Want to Do an Infrastructure Package [pdf]” · view on HN
Cites itcambalacheJan 2021

Explains why American public transit is poor.

Full comment

But that is not a fair comparison. You need to compare moving from NY, Amsterdam,Berlin, Madrid, Shanghai, Singapore, big cities with good public transportation to any big America city this video

in “Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in the world (2016)” · view on HN
Cites itnayukiApr 2023
Full comment

I can't speak for your situation, but I can tell you that Toronto made it work. Despite the fact that the majority of the land is single-family detached housing, it seems anyone is within a 1.0 km (0.6 mile) walk of a bus stop thanks to the bus grid. See: this video , link

in “Maps show how parking lots “eat” U.S. cities” · view on HN